Walnut Vase

James, for a beginner you did a great job. I like the shape and it shows off the walnut very well. Just one thing that I noticed. At the base your curve seems to go in, breaking the smooth flow of the overall curve of the vase. It might also be just the way the picture turned out. The camera angle can do some funny things to shapes.
Keep up the good work.
Steve

My opinion is not the same as Steve had. That reverse curve at the base looks good to me. This is a shape that is non-traditional, but it works.......

ooc