• It's time to cast your vote in the June 2025 Turning Challenge. (click here for details)
  • Congratulations to John Shannon"Cherry Bowl" being selected as Turning of the Week for June 30 2025 (click here for details)
  • Sign up for the 2025 AAW Forum Box Swap by Monday, June 30th (click here for details)
  • Welcome new registering member. Your username must be your real First and Last name (for example: John Doe). "Screen names" and "handles" are not allowed and your registration will be deleted if you don't use your real name. Also, do not use all caps nor all lower case.

May 2025 Challenge: Long Neck Hollowform

Status
Not open for further replies.

Michael Anderson

Super Moderator
Staff member
TOTW Team
Joined
Aug 22, 2022
Messages
1,914
Likes
6,276
Location
Chattanooga, TN
This month's challenge was inspired by the Canadian turner Tim Souter. On another forum he recently shared a couple of hollow forms he made that had exceedingly long necks. This is a form seen with weed pots, but not so often with hollow forms. Here are the two pieces he posted, the first in Pine, the second Dogwood:

638804095078315250.jpeg
638799638303225451.jpeg

These have hollow bottoms, as well as a hole that travels all the way through the neck. In Tim's case, he accomplished these by hollowing through the bottom, but there are alternative methods (e.g. think two-piece hollow form, or even a hollow form with an added long collar). I think/hope this is a challenge that can appeal to a wide variety of turners. In addition to this being a beautiful form, it requires some turning and work holding skills. Here is a reference video that may be helpful: Short vase with long neck.

Whatever method you end up using, be sure to have fun and challenge yourself. Feel free to embellish the form as desired, or leave it bare wood (as above). Here are the rules, as determined by AAW Forum legal counsel Dewey, Cheatum, and Howe:
  • Entries must be posted in this thread by ~11:59 pm Coordinated Universal Time (UTC) on May 28, 2025.
  • Feel free to post a maximum of two photos of your piece in this thread (I will use my favorite of the two when I create the voting thread).
  • Your piece can be any size, embellished or natural, one piece or multiple, and must have a hollow bottom and hole all the way through the neck. The latter is the most important requirement, and is likely honor system.
  • As always, this is a turning contest, not a "moldy oldie" photo contest, so in fairness to everybody, make sure your work is something you have made since this challenge was issued on May 11, 2025.
  • You may not post any photos of your entry in this month’s challenge in any other thread or in the gallery until the voting has ended and a winner has been declared.
  • Voting will take place from May 29, 2025, through 11:59 pm EST on June 1, 2025.
  • Solicitation of votes will result in disqualification.
  • The winner might have to pass a lie detector test before collecting the grand prize of a dogleg high-carbon continental gouge. Good luck, have fun, make shavings, and let the chips fall where they may!!
 
This one at least has me thinking about the possibilities; order of operatin, holding, design. WIth the month already half over, there's very little chance that I'll try it though.
 
This one at least has me thinking about the possibilities; order of operatin, holding, design. WIth the month already half over, there's very little chance that I'll try it though.
Gets me thinking the same things. Hey, you don’t have to make one for the challenge, but I’d still like to see what you can come up with in the future.
 
Gets me thinking the same things. Hey, you don’t have to make one for the challenge, but I’d still like to see what you can come up with in the future.

Here's one from about 15 years ago.
 

Attachments

  • PXL_20250515_034521225.MP.jpg
    PXL_20250515_034521225.MP.jpg
    330.9 KB · Views: 44
I did this as a learning experience. I’ve never made a segmented bowl (tried once but it exploded), never made a hollow form, and never entered anything I turned into a judged event. And sure as heck never turned a long neck vase.

I had nothing better to do today so this was my effort. 16.5” tall.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_7449.png
    IMG_7449.png
    2.6 MB · Views: 116
Well this is my entry even though it is much different then the sample, but I prefer long flowing continuous curves.
The wood is eastern white pine from the far northwestern edge of it's natural range, it was naturally occuring tree and cut a couple of miles north of my home. The 12 foot saw log was given to me then I milled it into several timbers including an 8 X 8 that I turned 2 6' barber poles, 6 X 6's and 2 X 8s - 2 X 10s - 2 X 12s. The vase was made from a cutoff 6 X 6 and has outside dimensions 5" diameter X 13" tall with the smallest part of the bore being 1.5" diameter. The item was turned with a dovetail tenon on each end and the outer contour completed. The boring of a 1.5" diameter hole all the way through was started with the base tenon griped in the chuck and the top end supported with a 3 wheel steady rest. The top flared opening was completed, except for the dovetail tenon. The vase was reversed to be driven by the top dovetail tenon, the hollowing of the base was completed, the dovetail tenon was removed and the opening was tapered to receive a plug. The final step was to make a plug with a 2" dovetail mortise and glue it in place.
25005Vasea.jpg25005Vase.jpg
 
Those are all very beautiful! Am I able to enter if I haven't completed my 30 day trial period. Like I guess I'm not an "Established member" yet until 30 days. This project looks fun and challenging
 
Last edited:
Those are all very beautiful! Am I able to enter if I haven't completed my 30 day trial period. Like I guess I'm not an "Established member" yet until 30 days. This project looks fun and challenging
Yep, you sure can! Looking forward to your entry. Cheers!
 
My entry is a last minute decision and definitely not planned 😁. I was looking for a dry piece of wood Saturday to practice a design with my new carver. When I chucked it up I thought about this challenge and look at the thread to see the requirements and decided to go for it.
Hollowed from the bottom, plugged, drilled through the neck to the bottom. Did a little carving and didn’t blow it up!
9-1/4” x 3-1/2 “

1748298269033.jpeg

1748298235821.jpeg
 
What do you use to drill a hole in something that deep? I have a Forstner bit extension, but because of the set screws, it will only go in an opening around 5/8" or bigger. I ordered some 12" brad point bits, but I'm concerned they won't run true. I plan on drilling from both top and bottom so the run isn't as long.
 
Kent, I guess I can't claim that the worm did it 😅 Actually I used a 12 inch long 3/16" drill bit from Home Depot but first with a regular drill bit with most of the bit in the chuck to start the hole. I then use the long bit and hope that it stays true guided by the first drilling. It usually works but you have to clear the bit regularly.
 
What do you use to drill a hole in something that deep? I have a Forstner bit extension, but because of the set screws, it will only go in an opening around 5/8" or bigger. I ordered some 12" brad point bits, but I'm concerned they won't run true. I plan on drilling from both top and bottom so the run isn't as long.
You could also use a gun drill but you would not find them at Home Depot.
The gun drills have a hole thru them for coolant however for drilling wood compressed air will clear the chips very effectively. The gun drill will stay centered if started true and can be hand held.
 
What do you use to drill a hole in something that deep? I have a Forstner bit extension, but because of the set screws, it will only go in an opening around 5/8" or bigger. I ordered some 12" brad point bits, but I'm concerned they won't run true. I plan on drilling from both top and bottom so the run isn't as long.
When I drill something like that, I normally use a gun drill (3/8" I got from Trent Bosch). If not using the gun drill I go with an electrician's bit (or aircraft bit). They're about 18" long. It's just a regular twist drill so it may wander depending on the wood/grain/etc. But if I give it a good start (start a hole with my spindle gouge) it's usually ok.
 
Don, I've seen gun drills but never smaller than 3/8 and also have no idea where to get them?
I got three at Boeing surplus when I was in Tacoma for the Symposium. The ones I got there are 3/8", 1/2" and 3/4" than after that a few years I saw 5 - 7/16" at an online machinery auction so I bid $20.00 and got them. This is what I have and the holder to use them. The 7/16" has a straight shank so I had to make an adapter to use it with my holder.DSC00850.JPG
 
Thank you everyone for participating! I'm also glad the challenge garnered some interesting discussion. I'm locking the thread, so no more entries. Kent, I'm going to use your Black Locust piece for your entry. It's great--but, send me a message if you want me to delete it from the upcoming voting thread.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top