• It's time to cast your vote in the June 2025 Turning Challenge. (click here for details)
  • Congratulations to John Shannon"Cherry Bowl" being selected as Turning of the Week for June 30 2025 (click here for details)
  • Sign up for the 2025 AAW Forum Box Swap by Monday, June 30th (click here for details)
  • Welcome new registering member. Your username must be your real First and Last name (for example: John Doe). "Screen names" and "handles" are not allowed and your registration will be deleted if you don't use your real name. Also, do not use all caps nor all lower case.

Reflections after a first year of woodturning

Joined
Feb 18, 2023
Messages
1,445
Likes
4,351
Location
Orange, CA
Having collected wooden bowls and forms for four decades, the creative process always intrigued and mystified me. How is this done? As a surgeon, working with my hands is something I love and I could appreciate the artistry and craft involved in turning. A year ago, I had never seen a lathe, did not know what a chuck looked like or was used for, and was mystified about what a gouge did—the latter sounded like something used by medieval torturers. I joined the Orange County Woodturners before I had even started turning, started Google searching and watching YouTubes about woodturning.

My timing was fortuitous, as Dick Foreman, an elderly and well-respected woodturner, was turning in, so to speak. I bought his Powermatic 3520A, some gouges and chucks, and he threw in wood blanks and 30 years of woodturning magazines. An elderly patient sold me more tools and gave me more wood blanks. I took a course at Rockler, turning my first bowl with a carbide scraper. I took another class there. I took a couple more classes at Woodcraft. Needless to say, I was hooked. My wife had a wary look every time she opened the front door, as the newly purchased tools, stains, oils, and equipment started showing up sometimes several times a day.

I started attending the monthly Orange County Woodturners meetings, watching the demonstrations and listening, being motivated by the skills of so many. I learned about the club mentor program and was lucky enough to have Bill Haskell willing to assist me—I’ve been often to his home shop to learn many aspects of turning. He has patiently tolerated my endless questions and frequent visits, advancing my learning. Fred Wilmott, another mentor, has shown me bandsaw technique and setup. I took two classes in Las Vegas with Jimmy Clewes, the second a two day one-on-one that significantly advanced my primitive skills. I watch YouTube videos, dozens of them, recognizing that there are many ways to turn a bowl—and not all of them on that site work for me. Leland Wong, a woodturner with a machine shop, upgraded and modified my Powermatic, greatly improving its capabilities.

I joined AAW (American Association of Woodturners) and started participating with trepidation on their internet forum—my caveman turnings were well received with friendly advice like, “learn to sand.” But I’ve persisted, met many people who offer kind and helpful advice, leading to the amazing World of Woodturners internet site where incredible craftsmen (and women) daily post their amazing work, something to which to aspire, but so enjoyable to view. And there are several other very worthwhile internet woodturning sites. And I think I’m slowly improving at turning.

It’s been a year since I started this hobby; I’ve now turned about 90 bowls and a couple platters, giving away (and throwing away) all but a couple—the wife says we have enough bowls. I’m passionate about it now. I’m still a beginner, but at least the bowls no longer take flight from the lathe, fewer funnels are being made, and I’m usually keeping the inside smaller than the outside. It’s a wonderful hobby and pastime that has endless creative avenues. I expected the process to be interesting and fun. My expectations have been wildly exceeded. Sawdust and wood shavings are in my soul now, unfortunately in many other places as well.

I write this mostly for other beginners or those who just contemplate beginning to turn—and wondering where to turn. It does not need to be a lonely process as there are many sources for assistance in shortening the learning curve and maximizing the enjoyment—join the AAW, join your local turning club, watch videos, participate on the woodturning forums, and find a mentor. Most of all, turn.
 
Thanks for sharing your story

lucky enough to have Bill Haskell willing to assist me

took two classes in Las Vegas with Jimmy Clewes

recognizing that there are many ways to turn a bowl—and not all of them on that site work for me

Two fine people to spend time with.
Bill does fantastic work. jimmy is the best TEACHER I have had the pleasure of working with

You have chosen excellent guidance and realized a fundamental truth.
There are many ways to do most things in turning
Finding what works for you is a key to success.

Enjoy
 
Alan, you have made impressive progress after only one year. Congratulations! You have a terrific attitude for learning, and I appreciate your humorous way of writing.
90 bowls in one year??? I've been turning on & off for 40+ years and don't think I've turned that many bowls in total !
 
Very nice summary and great work at trying to improve in the little things!! We all keep each other trying new ideas and never are afraid to share success or failure. That is what makes the turning community so great!
 
I took two classes in Las Vegas with Jimmy Clewes, the second a two day one-on-one that significantly advanced my primitive skills.

I just looked at his classes, and I'll see if I can sign up for one this year. My only class so far was last year with David Ellsworth. I learned a lot, but I'd also love to have some hands-on instruction on spindle turning, which appears to be part of Jimmy Clewes's classes.
 
Alan, thank you for sharing the inaugural year of your woodturning journey. Even after twenty years, I find it a never-ending learning experience. You are off to a roaring start. Ninety bowls in your first year is quite impressive. Like Tom Gall, I don't think that I have turned that many bowls in my twenty-year journey.

... fewer funnels are being made ...

I don't make funnels ... I call them sinks ...

image-jpeg.21753


That's my story and I'm sticking with it.
 
@Alan Weinberg

....and then along comes someone with an entirely different perspective on the learning process, and how that relates to individuality.

Get some basic knowledge from books and a few "professional" videos.....maybe even a class or two. THEN shut out the rest of the turning world and solve problems like your great grandpa would have done 100 years ago......on your own, using nothing but your own observations, talents and instincts. It's ALWAYS harder this way but you'll end up doing things like nobody else would do it. In doing so, you'll let your individuality become the main element of whatever you produce.

Also.....Turn like there is no such thing as powered sanding.

^^^^^ If that is the height of your bar, then your lathe turning will eventually become separate from everyone who does use power sanding to refine their turned surfaces. The one single and most important aspect of powered sanding is it becomes impossible to sculpt finely executed lathe-turned details. Concerning these "finely executed" lathe-turned details, the one thing that power sanding destroys, is perfect geometry in conjunction with perfect concentricity. These things kill any chance of having the fine details look anywhere near pleasing to the eye, because planes no longer intersect cleanly, and detail grooves become inconsistent throughout the circumference. The reason for this, is powered sanding ALWAYS removes more material from the long grain than it does from the end grain.

(Note: I do use powered sanding for the interiors of my bowls, because there is no effort to produce finely executed details here.)

-o-
 
@Alan Weinberg

....and then along comes someone with an entirely different perspective on the learning process, and how that relates to individuality.

Get some basic knowledge from books and a few "professional" videos.....maybe even a class or two. THEN shut out the rest of the turning world and solve problems like your great grandpa would have done 100 years ago......on your own, using nothing but your own observations, talents and instincts. It's ALWAYS harder this way but you'll end up doing things like nobody else would do it. In doing so, you'll let your individuality become the main element of whatever you produce.

Also.....Turn like there is no such thing as powered sanding.

^^^^^ If that is the height of your bar, then your lathe turning will eventually become separate from everyone who does use power sanding to refine their turned surfaces. The one single and most important aspect of powered sanding is it becomes impossible to sculpt finely executed lathe-turned details. Concerning these "finely executed" lathe-turned details, the one thing that power sanding destroys, is perfect geometry in conjunction with perfect concentricity. These things kill any chance of having the fine details look anywhere near pleasing to the eye, because planes no longer intersect cleanly, and detail grooves become inconsistent throughout the circumference. The reason for this, is powered sanding ALWAYS removes more material from the long grain than it does from the end grain.

(Note: I do use powered sanding for the interiors of my bowls, because there is no effort to produce finely executed details here.)

-o-
I see your point but prefer learning from the mistakes of others! I modeled my training after a surgical residency, a combination of academics, study, supervision, and practice. You wouldn’t want your intern operating and experimenting on you unsupervised! While I read all I could, and watched far too many YouTubes as well as learning from many (including you) on this forum, I am also spending many hours at the lathe experimenting and often “killing” some nice pieces of timber as I seek to improve technique and develop a style. I think one can have the best of both worlds.
 
I see your point but prefer learning from the mistakes of others! I modeled my training after a surgical residency, a combination of academics, study, supervision, and practice. You wouldn’t want your intern operating and experimenting on you unsupervised! While I read all I could, and watched far too many YouTubes as well as learning from many (including you) on this forum, I am also spending many hours at the lathe experimenting and often “killing” some nice pieces of timber as I seek to improve technique and develop a style. I think one can have the best of both worlds.

I get it, Alan......and, I suspect there are far more turners who follow the same path you're on than those who follow the path that I'm on. There's nothing wrong with that, with the exception that as I look back, I'm feeling lucky that I traveled the path less traveled.

Keep on turnin', my lathe-bound friend! :)

-o-

keep on turnin'.jpg
 
as I ponder this, I realize many of you had no choice. 30 years ago there was no internet, no YouTube, no AAW forums, many fewer books, and few turning clubs. It was virtually all self taught. I look at that like Galápagos Islands—inbreeding without genetic diversity. There are turners like Odie whose work is magical and amazing—but I’m sure it was a steep learning curve without mentors and assistance like what is available today.

I loved the conversation and thoughts—thanks.
 
Like the way you put it . There are some who rise above adversity and have the veracity to continue on their own imagination and then there are those who need a little help along the way. I kinds split the ways and use a little of both. Yes we all need imagination but we also need the fundamentals. Sometimes this is instinctive and some times a bit of a nudge from outside is what it takes.
 
Alan I wish I had done like you, join clubs, take classes, and watched videos. I had always built furniture as a hobby and my wife bought me a small Grizzly lathe. Where we lived I could not get internet, knew no one who turned, and spent 2-1/2 years trying to figure it out. We of course had internet at work but I worked and didn’t play on the internet.
We were finally able to get internet service and I spent every night watching videos. I don’t remember the first one but I do remember this person saying, “watch tool presentation and body movement and weed out the turners who use bad technique”. I’ve vastly improved the last two years due to this but still haven't been able to take a class. So I guess I’m self taught with help from YouTube😁
I have a passion for this and strive to improve with each piece I put on my lathe. I joined AAW last November and read a lot in the forums to learn, I just wish more members were active. And I still watch videos almost every night, I hope to take a class soon and join my local chapter.
 
One thing I have yet to try is to sharpen the way I sharpen my bench chisels and plane irons. Final is on 16000 grit stones and then strop. With those edges, I can go against the grain and still have clean surfaces. Not sure if it is worth it or not..... I blame my dad, but I am always experimenting...... Engineers, if it ain't broke, take it apart and fix it anyway....

robo hippy
 
Back
Top