• April 2025 Turning Challenge: Turn an Egg! (click here for details)
  • Congratulations to Kelly Shaw winner of the March 2025 Turning Challenge (click here for details)
  • Congratulations to Guillaume Fontaine for "Nebules" being selected as Turning of the Week for April 6, 2025 (click here for details)
  • Welcome new registering member. Your username must be your real First and Last name (for example: John Doe). "Screen names" and "handles" are not allowed and your registration will be deleted if you don't use your real name. Also, do not use all caps nor all lower case.

Axminster (new chucks) vs New Vicmarc

I have sk114's with the O'Donnell and others. I try to keep a set of small medium and large jaws on the chucks. It usually ends up being a "H" gripper, a "C" jaw so I can use face plate rings that I have set up for my vacuum plate and then the "G" gripper for larger bowls. I also have the colossus jaws for the "why am I doing this?" times.

I prefer the gripper jaws because it's just easier for me to make a tenon with 90 degree sides instead of putting the correct angle for a dovetail.

The main reason I went with the axminster was because of the stainless steel construction that was mentioned before. At the time I was turning a bunch of green wood and all I had was a grizzly chuck I had bought with the lathe so I figured no rust was better.
Each their own, but for me, making a dovetail is much simpler than a straight tenon. The actual cut is a simple push cut that takes no more than 2 or 3 seconds. Comes out perfect every time. You just need to grind a 3/4" or 1", scraper with the angle of the dovetail, and keep that for making your cut, which is just an extremely simple push cut. I would never want to use a straight cut unless I had to for some special needs, as the dovetail will always pull your chuck up to the flat. Also, after rough turning, it is just as simple to clean up the dovetail for the final turning.
I would think it would be such a waste of wood to use a straight tenon as to get any meaningful grip for most projects, your tenon length would have to be much longer than the 1/4" or less needed for a dovetail one.
I can go out to the shop later to take a photo if you would like to see better.
As to what chucks? I only have experience with Oneway, and Vicmarc. Started with Oneway as that was the lathe I briefly had. I probably had about 6 or so of them. Then started buying Vicmarc's and sold off a couple of my Oneways. I have 10 or 12 chucks now and never have to change jaws. Both chucks were fine, but prefer the Vicmarc's.
 
Last edited:
Each their own, but for me, making a dovetail is much simpler than a straight tenon. The actual cut is a simple push cut that takes no more than 2 or 3 seconds. Comes out perfect every time. You just need to grind a 3/4" or 1", scraper with the angle of the dovetail, and keep that for making your cut, which is just an extremely simple push cut. I would never want to use a straight cut unless I had to for some special needs, as the dovetail will always pull your chuck up to the flat. Also, after rough turning, it is just as simple to clean up the dovetail for the final turning.
I would think it would be such a waste of wood to use a straight tenon as to get any meaningful grip for most projects, your tenon length would have to be much longer than the 1/4" or less needed for a dovetail one.
I can go out to the shop later to take a photo if you would like to see better.
As to what chucks? I only have experience with Oneway, and Vicmarc. Started with Oneway as that was the lathe I briefly had. I probably had about 6 or so of them. Then started buying Vicmarc's and sold off a couple of my Oneways. I have 10 or 12 chucks now and never have to change jaws. Both chucks were fine, but prefer the Vicmarc's.
My straight tenon is no longer than your dovetail. Even though it's shown that way in the ad picture. The serrations on the gripper jaws are relatively small. Not like the hollow forms jaws that have a long tenon.
Maybe I'm doing it wrong, but it works for me so far. I just bought this set "BF" and am finding it really handy for some small stuff I'm working on.

 
My straight tenon is no longer than your dovetail. Even though it's shown that way in the ad picture. The serrations on the gripper jaws are relatively small. Not like the hollow forms jaws that have a long tenon.
Maybe I'm doing it wrong, but it works for me so far. I just bought this set "BF" and am finding it really handy for some small stuff I'm working on.

Small things, I guess you are right, for the most part I very seldom turn anything so small and would have such a limited use for me.
 
My Axminster SK100’s came with the standard C Jaws and I’ve not had any issues with grip. I did though get some small gripper Jaws very cheap and they’re my favourites now. I don’t turn many bowls though.
 
Back
Top