• July 2025 Turning Challenge: Turn a Multi-axis Weed Pot! (click here for details)
  • Congratulations to Bobby McCarly for "Hemostatmorphodon" being selected as Turning of the Week for July 7, 2025 (click here for details)
  • Welcome new registering member. Your username must be your real First and Last name (for example: John Doe). "Screen names" and "handles" are not allowed and your registration will be deleted if you don't use your real name. Also, do not use all caps nor all lower case.

Dream lathe

John-If you ever get the chance, go see one. It is art expressed as an exquisitely engineered, solid machine. The tool-rest post id is 40mm, and it locks up like Fort Knox. I can't wait to give one a spin when Tim gets his set up and running. He said if price were no object. For me it is, so I will never own one (or a fully blinged-out Platinum Tundra either, but a man can dream).
 
Jon Rista said:
Some are things I've come to like, SINCE buying a Powermatic (which is a good lathe, but its not my dream lathe. ;P ) One of these is the strait up and down nature of the headstock and tailstock. The Powermatic tailstock design, is angled...so that the front of the quill ends up back-set from the front bottom edge of the tailstock (which itself, is even further backset a bit, because of the size of the round clamping plate underneath the ways). The banjo then is also rather wide, with the tool rest front-oriented. This means that between the backset of the front of the quill, plus the width of the banjo, you have to extend the quill quite a bit just to contact the wood. The quill is stable, but, so much of its potential extension is just wasted over empty space. That made me notice and appreciate the design of the American Beauty all that much more, as you don't have to waste any quill extension that way.
Click to expand...
Jon, I have a PM 3520C and I agree with you on the design of the tailstock. I think PM designed the tailstock with a slant towards the back in order to increase the overall distance between centers. This extra distance (about 2") when the tailstock is hanging off the end of the lathe, has come in handy for me when I turned several baseball bats for my grandsons.
 
Jerry Bochenek said:
Jon, I have a PM 3520C and I agree with you on the design of the tailstock. I think PM designed the tailstock with a slant towards the back in order to increase the overall distance between centers. This extra distance (about 2") when the tailstock is hanging off the end of the lathe, has come in handy for me when I turned several baseball bats for my grandsons.
Click to expand...
That step back may be handy for baseball bats, but it requires running the quill out excessively for short things (and much of what I've turned in recent years is not long although often wide. It's an aggravation. I turn on a lot of 3520Cs for demos and teaching/taking classes. I don't own one (I did have a 3520B, which did not have that unfortunate design 'feature' -- given a choice between a B and a C, I'd leap for the B).
 
R Henrickson said:
That step back may be handy for baseball bats, but it requires running the quill out excessively for short things (and much of what I've turned in recent years is not long although often wide. It's an aggravation. I turn on a lot of 3520Cs for demos and teaching/taking classes. I don't own one (I did have a 3520B, which did not have that unfortunate design 'feature' -- given a choice between a B and a C, I'd leap for the B).
Click to expand...
As I mentioned to Jon, and I agree with you as well, that the PM tailstock is agravating and it does put stress on the quill during normal turning. I was only pointing out what "may" be PM's design ratrional for the slant back. I wasn't trying to defend their tail stock design.
 
I'm perfectly content with what would be described nowadays as the mid-sized lathe realm. I just didn't need the 24"x53" my old Vicmarc VL300 provided me. I'm thrilled by the high quality results I get from my 16" Vicmarc VL200 shortbed, and my Oneway 1224 with bed extension. I can turn tiny stuff, dinner plates, big popcorn bowls, baseball bats, vases, etc. no problem. If I had to downsize, the VL200 would be the one to go, pretty rare when I push its limits anymore.
 
Bought my dream lathe 13 years ago next month - Robust AB. 13 years down the road and it still runs like new and makes me grin just walking into the shop. It has done everything I’ve asked of it - big or small. Not a single component has failed, worn out or otherwise ceased to function, and it looks like that’s going to continue for the rest of my turning life.
Was it expensive? Oh yeah - took a while to save up. Was it worth it? Oh yeah - I’d do it all over again given the chance.
 
John Grace said:
Goodness gracious...4HP! What are you looking to turn?
Click to expand...
If powered by a VFD, motor output power diminishes directly proportional to speed. And torque does not increase; it remains constant for practical purposes from about 10% speed (can go lower with sensorless vector drive) up to rated speed. So a 4hp rated motor will produce roughly 1hp at quarter-speed. That's why seemingly large three-phase motors tend to be used on lathes.

Tim
 
I think the "dream" lathe for anyone depends a lot on what they like to turn or would like to turn.

Since I quickly dumped my first lathe almost 25 years ago (the deeply flawed clone of the old Craftsman monotube) and bought a "full sized" lathe, my dream lathe has been the one I see when I turn on the shop lights, whatever it is.

I have little desire to turn big bowls, green wood (too easy), incredible hollow forms - been there, done that. I'd be the worst production turner ever, bored to death after the 2nd piece. I don't turn to sell. Those who love such things might well benefit from one of the amazing lathes available today. I'm am glad others are keeping the lathe makers in business! (I try to keep the tool makers in business)

I love to turn mostly smaller things from dry wood, the harder the wood the better. I love experimenting with form and detail, the more unique the better. I usually make a variety of sketches before I mount wood on the lathe. I never get in a rush. I love doing demos and teaching, especially beginners.

A dream lathe for me is one of sturdy construction that spins with no mechanical slop when I turn it on, has adjustable speed and reverse, will accept all my existing chucks and accessories, and has a sufficiently long bed. I don't need Herculean power since sharp tools and patience can always replace brute force, and arguably with less potential drama.

The Jet1642 I bought in the early 2000s was perfect for me. Building a big stand-alone shop with central heat and air made turning even more enjoyable. Adding a second 1642 helped with teaching and special projects. Replacing one of those Jets with a used PM3520b with a bed extension embedded me firmly in dream land.

WV_boys_es_IMG_20170319_154641_356.jpg

And even the most amazing lathe in the world is not much fun without wood. Having a huge supply of dry blanks in adjacent rooms, in a variety of sizes, and of a multitude of species, is beyond priceless.

Life is good.

JKJ
 
Last edited:
With my current set up, I turn bowls on my Vic 240. I core on my Robust Liberty. I sand on my Beauty. For spindles, which I don't do many of, I go to either the Robust or the Vicmark. I do have 2 mini lathes dedicated to small boxes and threaded boxes.

robo hippy
 
Isaac Litster said:
img1.jpg


Would I have... Having a lathe is different from using it daily. Because of this, I want a Wadkin RU. With infinite money, I would refurbish it and modify it with some modern features, such as a VFD. How much would that weigh?
Click to expand...

I would be happy with an RS10. And if we're spending dream-money, I would have an AB or Vicmarc in there too. I would be down one wife though, with all that temptation.
 
No doubt about the ultimate dream lathe for quickly creating turnings.

A patternmakers lathe with a power feed carriage with tool rests for hand turning too. Not sure if anybody still makes them. Recently there was a locally advertised Oliver patternmakers lathe capable of 12' length with two carriages, one for each end of the turning. Plus outboard turning capacity of 4 feet. Went dirt cheap because of its length.

The ultimate machine for making bowl-like items would be a CNC milling machine. But this might not fit the description of a lathe.
 
My old Vicmarc VL100 mini lathe. 10"x15" capacity, I built it up on a Jet mini lathe stand and powered it with a new 3/4hp DC Leeson and Minarek drive. I sold it to make room for my friend's Vic VL200 when he downsized. For a few minutes, I owned the whole family- VL100/200/300. Only the 200 remains with me. I tracked down the VL100 a year ago to see if I could buy it back. It was sold to yet another loving home, and they aren't parting with it. I wish I'd kept it, 10 times better than every clone that came after it. Don't need it, just wanted it back if possible. The heart wants what the heart wants.
 
I have a Record Power Envoy and am very happy with it.
If you take away the $$ restriction I would say I would spring for a Robust AB, with some fun bells and whistles.
 
robo hippy said:
Oh, absolute best tailstock mechanism for getting it out of the way, Robust, by a long shot!
Click to expand...
Tailstock swing-away is an amazing thing. I'd thought to just heave-ho the tailstock out of the way when I'd originally planned on getting a Nebula, so getting swing away when I ended up with my Harvey T-60S was an unexpected gift. Bonus points for the mechanically simple design which creates a purely horizontal swing plane. It's nearly a one finger operation to swing it in or out of the way.
 
Chris Seymour said:
I have a Record Power Envoy and am very happy with it.
If you take away the $$ restriction I would say I would spring for a Robust AB, with some fun bells and whistles.
Click to expand...
If I were starting from the ground up in this craft, the Record Power lathes would be a serious contender for my dollar.
 
Robust AB is the finest woodworking machine I ever owned albeit for a short time. The machining is impeccable and when I say impeccable I mean no shims are required. And Brent at Robust is absolutely fantastic in the customer service department.
 
I would agree with others - Robust American Beauty. I always wish that I had bought the AB instead of the Powermatic 3520, but being in my 70's it was hard to justify more than double the cost for the Robust lathe. I have never found anything to be dissatisfied with on the Powermatic except the paint job on the lathe which chips off constantly in places that I don't even work near. Robust's lathe would look like new at this point while my Powermatic looks like it's way older than the 3+ years I've owned it. Otherwise, both great lathes.
 
John Grace said:
Robust AB is the finest woodworking machine I ever owned albeit for a short time. The machining is impeccable and when I say impeccable I mean no shims are required. And Brent at Robust is absolutely fantastic in the customer service department.
Click to expand...
have to agree - it was a stretch when I bought it 13 years ago - but when I considered that I would be retiring in a couple of years, I took the leap while I could make up the difference. It has been a flawless piece of equipment ever since and shows no signs of slowing down or wearing out. Still get a grin on my face everytime I walk into the shop...gotta love the Beauty.
 
My Nova DVR3000 is 23 or 24 years old and still looks like new. My Powermatic will be 20 years old this October (I have a picture of it still boxed laying on the shop floor and not put together because I was going to my first symposium, Turning 2005) and it is very clean considering how many pros have used it (sometimes a pro would do something to my lathe that I would never do). My Nova Mercury and the little Vicmarc are the oldest of my lathes because I bought them from my club and they had been with the club since it started so they were older than the club as they were donated and I believe they are both older than 26 years. The Vicmarc has a very low serial number from I think from Craft Supplies. My Jet 16" lathe is about 17 years old and my Nova Neptune is about 3 years old. I take good care of all of them. They are all cast iron. I do have 1 other and that is a 12" 3/4 hp cast iron lathe from Vevor as I could not believe I could buy a lathe like that from China via Los Angeles for $285.95 delivered. It was delivered and I have made this my pen lathe and it works just fine, it is about 5 years old.
 
I bought my Robust AB a few months ago and love it. When ordering it spoke with Brent about turning height since I like to turn a bit lower using long handled tools riding my hip (not great for spindles but I don’t do a lot of that) and it shipped to me at the precise height we discussed . . . it’s the little things that sometimes matter.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top