Absolutely the toughest part is holding the tools consistent!!!! I also was used to the x n y method ( wouldn't mind having that option on a wood lathe though. I am a bit concered about turning aluminum, the "string" chips generated could be dangerous!! Wher would you get "cast acrylics??"
As for holding the tools, I'll repeat what some of the best turners I know, in person and by reputation, have said about tool control - developing expertise at spindle turning can teach the hands and eyes the fine tool control that will allow turning
anything, something that the common starting and sticking to turning bowls doesn't always do. So spindle turners, keep at it!
This is where I last bought cast acrylic rod but it's not cheap. There are probably other suppliers.
https://www.delviesplastics.com/p/Color_Acrylic_Rod.html
I've only bought 1.5" rod. I got started on this when someone in the plastics business brought a number of short colored pieces to a class to give away. Almost no one was interested except for me so I took home almost all of them! I wish I could find some short pieces of 3" dia rod - I'd love to try making some lidded boxes, maybe threaded.
One thing, I found out the hard way that the less color-dense plastic got almost transparent when turning thin. Before turning the green handbell ornament, I made a bell part with a nice piece of blue rod. When it got thin it was almost transparent, no good color at all! Duh.. I did have one short piece that looked almost black, but when I held it up the the light I could barely see some green at the thinner edges. When turned thin, it was fantastic. I make these bells very thin at the rim, graduating to much thicker where the handle connects.
In case anyone's interested, here's a handbell ornament made from the rosewood "tulip wood" that got cracked on one trip to Europe. So I cut it in half to show the construction! Look how thick the wall is away from the rim!
BTW, these ornaments may look complicated to make, but as my piano teacher always said, everything's easy once you know how. I did a demo on these at one TN club - I took blanks for the bells and handles and pieces of brass wire so I could hand out kits. I was surprised - about a dozen people made them and brought them to the next meeting.
The one in the earlier message is the only one I made to completion from plastic so far. I've made a BUNCH of these wood and given them away. I'd go to peoples houses years later and see them in a display case. Made me smile!
Me at a demo (10 years ago before I lost a bunch of weight!)
And before a club genius set up a state-of-the art video system!
Oh, I didn't think turning the aluminum was the least bit dangerous. Annoying, though, having to stop often to clear aluminum strands that were getting wrapped around the lthe spindle. The same thing with acrylic, worse but easier to clear. Brass, no problems.
JKJ