I teach beginners bowl turning and that is a question sometimes raised and I do not have a good answer. Why are most bowls turned in a cross grain orientation?
Turn A Wood Bowl +2
Turn A Wood Bowl +4Both side grain and end grain bowls have drawbacks and both can present the grain in an attractive fashion.End grain bowls are highly prone to cracking as the pith remains. A properly cut cross grain blank removes the pith thereby mitigating against cracking.
"Also some big sassafras"When I turn end grain bowls, boxes, and vessels I NEVER leave the pith. This may require having access to larger blanks. I also normally let them dry first so cracking from drying is not a problem.
I think one reason is as Mark mentioned - bowl and platter blanks are typically cut from either lumber or from easily acquired green log sections. These are limited in size for many due to the means of loading, hauling, and working with huge blanks. Far easier to cut and manhandle cross-grain blanks, green or dry, from smaller log sections. When I get logs up to about 28" I usually slice them up on the sawmill - it's easy to cut and handle even thick slabs.
That said about large blanks - when I get big wood people who turn big things (cowboy hats, big bowls, etc) come with a truck or trailer. I can usually gently load even large log sections with the excavator. I have a 36" y.poplar tree coming down soon as well as a 28" red oak. Also some big sassafras and other species.
I'm in the process of clearing and prepping a site for a new building. Took down 14 smaller (10 to 18") trees recently by digging around the roots and either pushing and/or pulling them over. Doing this with most trees over 24" diameter scares me!
An exception: this pine was about 36" in diameter at the base BUT it was already leaning in a good direction with enough clear space that it wouldn't get hung up in other trees. Had to dig around the roots 4' down and 6' across before it would budge:
View: https://youtu.be/iTx7IDZ8sQQ
Once, however, a friend called me with some beautiful ambrosia maple log sections about 40" across. Took a lot of chainsawing to make pieces small enough for us to load in my truck and years of drying blanks but I now have some big end-grain pieces to turn.
BTW, for those who have a suitable trailer it's relatively easy to load even large logs (as long as they are round with limbs removed) with just a rope or a chain and a couple of improvised ramps (I use two 10' lengths of i-beam). Look up "parbuckling". Many time I've hauled a big trailer to a site with the truck, wrapped a chain around the log, rolled the logs by pulling on a chain with the truck or a car, then tied down and drive home. Can even load by hand with several helpers.
JKJ


StrengthI teach beginners bowl turning and that is a question sometimes raised and I do not have a good answer. Why are most bowls turned in a cross grain orientation?
Lennart,Wood moves with moisture changes. Your design must always take this into account. This is easier for cross grain bowls. For end grain bowls this is much more difficult, unless you just use half logs. However, with suitable shape which lets it deform without stresses it is possible, this usually requires a small diameter bottom and fairly sloping walls. Also note that you must turn it from green wood, let it dry and do the final touch up. Example here in oak 29x13 cm, foot 5 cm diam.
View attachment 85720 View attachment 85721
Another alternative is to split in half logs, dry and glue together before turning, or even better, turn green with thick walls, split and let dry, glue together and finish turn. Here willow
View attachment 85722
You cannot leave the walls thick as normal twice turning and then turn it again. It must be fairly thin at the bottom to avoid splitting.Lennart,
Is it better to rough the end grain bowl and twice turn it? I assume thats what you meant by let it dry then touch it up?
You cannot dry the blanks with pith, however carefully. Radial and tangential shrinkage are different and will make them crack.This very subject is where i am at right now, have a bunch of logs that i need to deal with before they start checking and deteriorating on me, i need to get them blanked into useable pieces that i can turn at a later date. Have a feeling the end grain slices will be the toughest to keep viable because of the pith, not a total loss if they check, can fill with resin, but prefer to just have good blanks so am trying to figure out a path forward. Am planning on dicing stuff up as close as possible to pieces i can handle and end coating them and sticking them on shelves to dry/sit till i have time to turn them.
Creating blanks for taller vessels is one of the things im curious about, figuring i need to just rough out larger square long shapes like 8x8 or 10x10 etc and as long as i think i can pull off, or handle safely, say 12 to 20 or so inches.
Some of the smaller branches i am thinking of just turning end grain whole piece vessels and bowls, am thinking i need to leave them a bit longer and seal the hell out of the ends to reduce cracks. Sorta frustrating really, get going with saw and chalk in hand then go blank standing there looking at the piles, but i know i cant just leave whole logs as i will end up with big piles of compost!
Thats kinda what i figured, long term nothing with the pith will survive. Pretty much like lumber.You cannot dry the blanks with pith, however carefully. Radial and tangential shrinkage are different and will make them crack.



Like Lennart said about shape applies but that does not mean that it won't survive.Thats kinda what i figured, long term nothing with the pith will survive. Pretty much like lumber.


Now thats the way to have blanks!PROCESSING AND DRYING BLANKS
Tom, I've cut and dried many 100s, maybe 1000s of blanks over the years, mostly end grain for boxes, vessels, etc, and have had very few failures. Of course we don't have the same wood species but I do process a variety. Almost all of my blanks are square or rectangular, from 1/2" square up to 12", and various lengths. The length doesn't matter except for the drying time. I use Anchorseal - note that it's basically blended paraffin wax, water, and a surfactant to let the water and wax play together well.
I find several things important.
Even after sealing, some blanks can start to develop cracks. How I save them:
- Cut away any visible cracks in the log section or after cutting the log into blanks. This does not prove there are no invisible cracks which will come back to haunt you later.
- After cutting away any visible blanks, cut off one additional thin section from the end grain - maybe 1/8" to 3/16" thick. This is easier after the wood is cut into square or rectangular blanks which can sit flat on the bandsaw table. Bend that thin section and see if it cracks or breaks in two. If it does, cut away a little more and repeat the bend. Keep cutting until NO thin sections will crack.
- Best to immediately seal that end with Anchorseal
- Note that I never use Anchorseal as provided but always thicken it first. That will result in a thicker coat of wax and seal much better. (It doesn't work so well to apply a second coat later since you will be applying water to paraffin and it won't coat effectively. To thicken Anchorseal I pour about 1" or so into a plastic coffee can and let is sit without the lid of for a few days or weeks, whatever it takes to thicken it. I keep a cheap brush in the can and stir occasionally. When it's thick enough to suit me, I put the lid on with the brush inside. When that coat starts to get low I may start another can or simply add and mix some new Anchorseal, stir it around, and let that thicken.
- If I can't apply Anchorseal immediately I might submerge the blanks in a tub of water or spritz them with water and put them in a plastic bag for overnight. (If left in a plastic bag TOO long, depending on the temperature, the wood may well begin to spalt. This can be wonderful or turn to rot.
- I also seal the side grain of some blanks, for example the sides of blanks of some species (dogwood is a good example) where the both the heart wood are visible on the side. (The two dry and shrink at much different rates and can crack along the where they meet) I also seal any side grain that is highly figured, such as burl.. I seal some blanks on all 6 sides.
- After trimming both ends and sealing, I put the blank on a wire shelf to air dry, making sure the species and date are written on the side of each piece. Do not use a fan or heat to accelerate drying. I dry inside my climate=controlled shop.
Actually, I don't forget about them, but start monitoring the moisture content after a few more weeks.
- I'd rather have smaller good quality blanks than longer blanks. I don't do crack filling.
- After letting them air dry for a week or several weeks I examine each blank for cracks that are starting to form in spite of the sealing.
- If I find any developing cracks, they go back to the bandsaw to be cut away. Since the blank has been drying for a bit much of the water has already left the ends of the blank and remaining water gradient inside has started to equalize.
- I test thin slices as before for hidden cracks. When all good, the cutaway ends or sides get another coat of sealer, put back of the shelf. I'll recheck a time or two then put them up and forget about them
- Note that on some occasions I leave some cracks in the wood. And example is some spindle blanks where I know I'll hold one end in a chuck and cut it away as waste at the end. A few short, minor cracks won't hurt anything.
- I mark ALL visible remaining cracks, even if they are in a place that will probably be cut away. When I grab a dry blank to turn, this alerts me to examine the blank to make sure it will work for that turning.
What about moisture meters? I have both pinless an pin moisture meters. The problem with both of these is unless the blank is almost dry there can be a moisture gradient with the blank (wetter in the center than towards the surfaces) and the meters are not accurate. Both types are more suited to boards than thick turning blanks. The pin type won't measure much deeper than you drive the pins. The pinless will measure a little deeper but not deep enough for turning blanks. The pinless meters, at least the one I have, require a flat spot to fit the sensor area on the meter. I think the best way is to monitor the weight.
- I separate the blanks into lots of the same species, blanks roughly close in sizes. I put a piece of green Scotch 2060 masking tape on the side o the blank, weigh with a precise scale, and write the month, day, and the weight in grams on the tape.
- Every few months I weigh again and record the month and the weight. The weight will drop and when it quits dropping that blank and those of similar size in the same batch are dry. The original strong moisture gradient inside has equalized and the wood is at EMC for that environment and can be safely turned. The weight may even go up a little with seasonal changes, but they are still dry.
For end grain bowls or vessels, or boxes, I may partially turn the outside and maybe the inside after drying a bit, then reseal and continue drying. If the piece is getting close to dry there's not much reason to reseal.
Here are some blanks I cut up on the sawmill and trimmed the ends with the chainsaw, ready to take inside to prepare for drying.
View attachment 86655
Some blanks I cut up one afternoon, ready to stack on the drying shelves.
![]()
2x2s might dry in a few weeks. Large blanks of some species might that 5-10 years. Have enough on hand and the drying time is no problem - there is ALWAYS plenty of dry ready to pick of the shelf and dry.
Since I even prefer to turn bowls dry, I'll first dry the blank then cut a round bowl blank. The will dry faster if rounded first but they will warp out of round and still might develop cracks on the end grain. This is, of course, a side/face grain blank.
View attachment 86658
TURNING WET
For those who prefer to turn wet sopping wood, not much of this matters. Best thing is to keep the wood wet until. ready to turn, rough, seal and dry or simply turn to finished thickness. The worst thing to do is wait too long until checks and deep cracks have started to form on the end grain. In this case, cut away enough to remove the cracks and test for hidden cracks as before.
The late great John Jordan woodturner said to avoid all this he just bought whole logs and stored them off the ground out of the sun. If necessary, he would hire someone to deliver the log. When ready to turn a piece, he'd cut about 6" off the end and throw that piece away. Then mark and cut the blank he wanted and take it inside and turn it. He obviously turned green.
He gave me a blank once of the size he used for many hollow forms. I took it home, sealed it, and put it up to dry.
This is my favorite kitchen scale for weighing, higher capacity than most, accurate, I have three. $10 more a few years back but that's life in today's world. I've tried multiple scales and like this one best.
www.amazon.com/dp/B07QP4XQNV
This it my favorite tape to use around that lathe to support things and for labels that will stick or concrete block and wet wood. It is NOT your father's masking tape, nothing like the stuff from the big box store. Scotch 2060 masking tape for rough and 'hard to stick' surfaces. We also use it in the kitchen to label containers for the fridge and things that go in the freezer, to label containers and boxes in the shop. To tape up things that need to stay together. To provide extra holding when jam chucking or using Cole jaws, turning the detail in the top of a box lid. (tape the lid to the base.) I've found a multitude of uses.
Best tape ever. I buy it in widths from up to 2" for labels, narrower for other uses. I write on it with fine and extra-fine black Sharpies.
View attachment 86659
JKJ
I like the little feet, that must have taken some time to rough those out. I think my biggest problem will be not cutting too thin, almost went through a little bowl i was fooling with today, kept screwing up my last cut in the center on the inside, kept telling myself, “ a little more wont hurt “ its pretty thin.Like Lennart said about shape applies but that does not mean that it won't survive.
View attachment 86660View attachment 86661
These 2 bowls were turned with the pith from northern red oak (MN US) and they survived without ever cracking on the pith and just looking at Lennart's bowl I wouldn't expect to be a problem.
Yikes, on last inventory I had at least 125 species. If I don't at least write the names on the wood I'm hopelessly confused later, especially when some wood darkens.i made a jig that sits on the mill with a couple long bar clamps and can hold blocks, shorts, small logs etc from 8”- up to 7’.
...i basicly just have 4 species im cutting, and all are pretty distinct,

